The Turnpike CIC was a bold, independent not-for-profit arts project with community at its heart, based in Leigh, Greater Manchester.

This web archive, titled Could this be paradise? reflects on our 5 years in Leigh, highlighting the community voices and artists who have worked with us to shape our organisation.

We want to say a huge thank you to our Turnpike family; the team members, volunteers, artists, community members, peer organisations, funders and supporters who have invested their energy, creativity and ingenuity with us over the years.

Introduction
Helen Stalker in conversation with Juliet Jacques
In March 2022, Director Helen Stalker spoke with writer, filmmaker, journalist and founder and presenter of Resonance FM art discussion show ‘Suite (212)’, Juliet Jacques about her experiences of founding, running and wrapping up The Turnpike CIC.
Juliet Jacques - JJ
So we're going to discuss the five years that you've been working with the Turnpike in Leigh and perhaps we could just kick off by you telling me how you got involved with the project in 2017 and why and what you were hoping to achieve?
Helen Stalker - HS

I’d had quite a few years of experience working for big cultural organisations like Tate Liverpool and I was at the Whitworth in Manchester for 10 years. But for some time, I'd been living in Leigh, which is a small town equidistant between Liverpool and Manchester within the Greater Manchester framework. I was commuting every day in and out of Manchester, to somewhere like the Whitworth which had recently undertaken a beautiful capital redevelopment project, was devising and hosting important, ambitious exhibitions and had an impactful engagement programme. I was really aware of the disparity of opportunity around culture in a place like Leigh and the Turnpike Gallery was something that, like many people within the sector, and beyond, I was very aware of. I knew it had had this really interesting history of supporting a lot of artists in their early days who then became key artists nationally, particularly artists from the Northwest. It was a ballsy little gallery with a great legacy.

And kind of a surprising space in a town like Leigh. It is a brutalist, concrete, future focused piece of architecture built on what was the market square and so quite a radical thing, really, from the 1970s.

When austerity really bit hard, particularly in the North of England, and local councils were making some tough decisions, the gallery closed down as did Drumcroon, which was a really pioneering centre of excellence for cultural education in Wigan. So for both organisations to go was a double blow for the area.

Luckily, after its closure, the gallery continued to be ringfenced for the arts by a team of really active volunteers, which meant it was protected from being repurposed as something else.When the opportunity came about to take it on, it was a real leap of faith, but thankfully one that other people and organisational partners took with me.

I developed a community interest company (The Turnpike CIC) in order to run a cultural offer and to try to devise a way that would create an arts legacy for that town; to deploy culture, hopefully in a really useful way for my own community. So from there, you know, just kind of flew by the seat of my pants.

JJ
So what you're describing there sounds to some extent, like a response to austerity, and particularly the way that austerity was enacted through local councils and local authorities.
HS
Yes, it was. I mean, I know there are some tough decisions to be made and often culture is the first thing to get axed. But it was really disturbing to me, not only as somebody invested in the arts, but as a local Mum, raising a child here. We know that culture is seen as expendable, it's a ‘nice to have’ and The Turnpike became a mission to demonstrate that it could be more than that. It was never going to be this thing, Juliet, was it, where we’ll have some good exhibitions that a few people would come to and then house prices will go up because they're in proximity to a nice art gallery. It was always going to have to work harder than that. So that leap of faith was a gut response to austerity for sure.
JJ
That was a lot of new Labour's cultural policy in places outside of London, wasn't it? Like, you know, if we build an art gallery in Walsall it will turn into Bilbao, and life doesn't really work like that.
HS
If you build it, they will come?
JJ
I think, partly in response to that, the Brexit vote in Leigh was the biggest, I think, in the Northwest or at least in the Liverpool Manchester region. And we'll come back to the media framing of this, but this maybe sets the tone for what you were doing and the importance of creating a place for the arts in that context?
HS

What strikes me most about Leigh is how its sense of place is rooted in the pride it feels for its heritage. It has had its knocks with the decline of the mining industry, the Thatcher era and has been hard bitten by austerity and underinvestment. And like many post-industrial towns, it has survived by being fiercely independent and community driven. And really the way the community activated itself was through this sense of, ‘well, we'll look after ourselves then, thanks very much’. The town is activated through community interest companies, community organisations, and volunteer-led organisations and there’s that push to say, let’s look after ourselves and let’s look after each other. Through an ideological lens, I suppose you’d say there’s a definite co-supportive eco system happening here, but on the flip side, this could also reduce context and create insularity in terms of the conversations that can happen and the level of aspiration that’s seen as achievable.

The Brexit vote happened before we took on the gallery, but the result was something that personally really triggered something in me to say: let's look at expanding those horizons, expanding those conversations, bringing in broader contexts. And one of the great ways to do that is through the arts.

JJ
In the national media at the time of the general election in 2019, much of the attention was centred around Leigh as they brought this term ‘red wall’ into being having never previously used it before. And there was a breathtakingly stupid article about Leigh and the people of Leigh apparently being glad that they didn't vote Labour. And I remember, for example, they were interviewing people who were too young to vote. So, you know, I think it's fair to say Leigh is a place that has not been particularly well represented in the media at various points in time.
HS
I think that the frustration felt around the media coverage was quite apparent locally. There was a serious lack of perspective and creative thinking, and any kind of radical debate was excluded from all of that as well. As a cultural organisation we were developing projects which really unearthed and opened up a dialogue around Leigh and particularly with young people, you know, around what their future vision was, the aspirations they had for their town, how they wanted to break out of the mould. So there was all of this really dynamic dialogue going on that was apparent amongst us all that was so vibrant and so vital. And then you turn on the telly. And it became a bit of a running joke because there was this one spot in the marketplace next to the jumpers…
JJ
John Harris just set up a little shack there?
HS
Well basically, this was the spot that all the journalists went to, and they got one perspective and talked to the same stall holders, the same people. And you know, I love Leigh market, there's nothing wrong with the market whatsoever. But I was phoning up news outlets saying, ‘come and see us, come and talk to the people were engaging with, or maybe go and talk to that person, or this group?’ But there was such a lack of interest in actually breaking out of any other narrative than the one they'd formed. Like you say, it's a kind of reinforced mythology around working class towns, and it just became a self-perpetuating story that the situation was ‘this’. When actually the day after the election results came through a lot of people were in a state of disbelief. Chatting to people that morning, many actually felt a kind of failed responsibility to their parents and their grandparents and their own heritage.
JJ
I mean, I have lots of opinions on British media culture, and none of them are good. I was living in Hackney at the time and the Labour vote did hold up there partly because Diane Abbott is just hugely personally popular. But very similar in Hackney, people were just really traumatised and scared. And you know, again, the media narrative about Hackney is that these days it’s been gentrified, but huge swathes of Hackney are really, really poor. And there’s a large black community on the wrong end of a lot of the police — institutional and social racism and all the rest of it. So actually, it's not just the places outside of London that get this narrative.
HS
On the back of all of this though we're running a cultural organisation. It doesn't matter what our political leanings are as individuals. It’s a place that welcomes, to a large extent, the broadest range of opinions. But I think our responsibility is to just open up strategies and ways of broadening contexts and expanding the way Leigh is seen and the way people see the world beyond Leigh. I'm not politically pigeonholing the organisation it's more about our frustration at seeing how myopic that positioning was really.
JJ
Well let’s take a slightly more positive turn and talk about the specific projects that you were doing, I think, before the end of 2019, and maybe we could talk about some of the highlights of your programmes before the pandemic.
HS

Yeah, sure there are some standouts. And, and it's often those stand out projects which really crystallise, what it is that you want to do and what you think is going to work. We began with humble means but with big aspirations, so we partnered with organisations like Liverpool Biennial to enable us to bring international artists and global perspectives to Leigh. Our programme was centred on exploring local themes but connecting them up with big conversations. So, for example, we exhibited the Algeria-born artist Mohamed Bourouissa’s Horse Day in 2019, an amazing work about marginalisation, community activism and collective spirit. We exhibited four or five large exhibitions like that each year and firmly embedded throughout was an active programme of engagement and participation.

In the Summer of 2019, our thinking took a bit of a turn when we were selected as the host organisation for the Alexandra Reinhardt Memorial Award and worked with the artist Lindsey Mendick. Lindsey had this great idea to form a collective: a group of artists working in clay in a really radical way. Throughout the summer the collective worked in partnership with Wigan Targeted Youth Services with a group of looked after young people to form ‘The Turnpike Pottery’. And the culmination of that was just this explosion of celebration of young activism and confidence; a celebration of youth voice through this medium, and it was a riot of colour, and it was just fantastic. It should have been nominated for the Turner Prize, I think it was absolutely beautiful.

But what we gained through that project as an organisation was a revived focus. Through that process we saw a tangible shift in the way that we operated, which was around creating a collective, creating a dialogue, and broadening out the conversation: handing over that kind of curatorial space, granting permission I suppose. Enabling people to have deep-rooted, longer-term engagement rather than a ‘flash in the pan’ project that then parachutes off again. And so from this learning, we decided to create a new way of working which we called Activations.

We began the process with the Liverpool-based artist Francis Disley who worked with a group that we've known for quite a while called Fallen Angels Dance Theatre. Through regular dance sessions, they work regularly with people in recovery from addiction. And she created this incredible project with them over a long period of time, in and out of lockdown. It triggered a more radical approach to delivery, actually just prior to the first Covid lockdown.

JJ
Yeah, let's talk a bit more specifically about what you did in lockdown. So we last spoke, I think in Summer 2020. It was an episode of my radio show Suite (212) with you and Stefan Kalmár from the ICA. It was quite an interesting comparison between a really large, globally famous London based institution, and then a much more local, community focused gallery, The Turnpike. And there was a reason why I chose The Turnpike as a point of comparison and contrast to the ICA because I think the model you were working with was really interesting. You've already talked about the ways in which some of the projects you were working on were quite readily adaptable to this unforeseen circumstance, but what was specifically created in response to the crisis?
HS

We were able to do a huge amount of work and actually, for much of the time, it felt busier than ever during lockdown. We placed our Activations programme front and centre of our activity and enabled these projects to really work within this context: this weird new world context that we all found ourselves operating in.

For example, we’d already started a commissioned project, These Lancashire Women are Witches in Politics with the artists Anna FC Smith and Helen Mather who were amazing, as were most of the artists that we worked with, in just reimagining and reshaping what they were offering. When we were all isolating, they engaged with people collectively online, sending out materials to people to create works of art. The central message of the process was around, women's roles in political activism, in particular, the demonisation of working class women engaged in activism. It was a great vehicle for creating solidarity and, a bit like Lindsey's project, it went from a two person exhibition into 100 person commission. It really chimed with the idea of democracy, with the idea of creativity as a connector. And that culminated in all of those objects coming back to us; ceramic sigils, embroidered banners and ceramics to form a celebratory exhibition – a kind of reunion when we reopened.

We’ve been really lucky to have worked with the artists that we've worked with and to have seen how they’ve deployed themselves in that way. They adapted brilliantly to the circumstances. For Frances Disley’s piece, the dancers ended up meeting in a local park. And then when the first lockdown lift happened, and we were able to do things within restricted parameters, they came back into the gallery and the piece Epic Luxe was produced, which we showcased at the Northern Powerhouse Conference. And it was a work of art of its time; resilience, transformation, creativity. It's just really beautiful.

Interestingly, Juliet, some of the people we were working with were Covid-sceptic. So we found ourselves dealing with protest.

JJ
Right, interesting.
HS

It was, but we just used it as an opportunity to really great conversation about, ‘it doesn’t really matter what happens within the political sphere and where your position is, but we do need to care for each other and be kind to each other.’

We became a bit of a testbed for continuity, for example, bringing in children who were transitioning into secondary school to work with artists in order to build confidence. We did this in ‘bubbles’ in partnership with Curious Minds. Some of our work seemed really quite low-key, like we took over the brutalist, concrete flower beds at the front of the gallery and created a recovery garden. And we did a walking project with the artist Niki Colclough. And I know that all sounds quite gentle, doesn't it? But actually, it was about people coming together and taking the opportunity to actively reimagine and re-evaluate the place where they lived most of their lives.

We knew that we couldn’t just shut our doors and say, okay, well we'll get some emergency money and we'll sit tight, and we'll ride it out. So we occupied our green spaces, our civic spaces, our virtual spaces. It just meant that we could work within these ever-shifting parameters and keep going, and so could our communities.

Outdoor spaces actually became a really important aspect of our provision. We ended up partnering with Lancashire Wildlife Trust on a project we called Wanderland, which opened up those outdoor spaces for community action and creativity. We did that because the Wildlife Trust wanted to test out these new ways of working with artists and using these spaces in a less predictable way. With young people, particularly, their engagement with these often underused green spaces allowed us to then open up more conversations around climate action and climate justice. We didn't want that to amplify anxiety, but it became a focal point during lockdown and we wanted to make sure that these young people were using these spaces for cultural activism. I think, through engagement with that unique kind of biodiversity on their doorstep, even if it was the concrete flower bed at the front of the gallery, there's a connection there that reinforces that message.

JJ
Well, that's really interesting how you navigated the lockdown. And obviously, things started opening up again, really when the last lockdown ended in April last year. So perhaps it'd be nice to just talk a bit about the last year of The Turnpike and what you've been doing.
HS

Yeah, sure. Well, I'll backtrack slightly in saying that we didn't get emergency funding from the Arts Council, but we did manage to secure project funding for the Activations programme which was a bit of a miracle. We didn't get that much-needed money that would have supported us unconditionally, but then we're used to that. But what that pot of project money did enable was for us to continue to engage. One of the big things that we did start in lockdown was the Making of Us artists’ development programme, which we're actually wrapping up today. That has been a two-year programme with two cohorts of artists from across Greater Manchester, supported through the GMCA Culture Fund. And that was a cross partnership project where artists were connected up to care providers, youth organisations and autism organisations, to develop their own practice, but also for us to lay fruitful ground for ongoing socially engaged practice by developing this local cohort of artists. It’s all very well, us talking about local provision, but if we don't provide opportunities for the artists to actually lead that local provision in the long term, then there's a failure there.

There's all the evidence and the learning outcomes from that project which we hope will establish a strong model for artists’ development projects for the future. And so that, and other legacy building projects, have been a big part of our final year.

We centred ourselves on bringing people back together, again. Workshops, re-uniting people and bringing new people into the gallery as well as reviving the cultural education programme, because we were really mindful that schools had suffered, children and young people and the broader community were needing this point of connection and joy again.

JJ
That comes to something that I find quite interesting. I’d just like to get your opinion, really. I mean, earlier you referred to the Turner Prize, talking about community and how one of your commissions should have been nominated for it. And obviously, the Turner Prize made some quite interesting responses to COVID, which partly come out of something that has happened before. So in 2019, as you know, the Turner Prize was shared, because the four artists agreed they wanted it to be that way. In 2020, they gave out a series of bursaries to 10 artists rather than having a prize. In 2021, all of the nominees were a kind of collective, so were doing quite community focused work. And I wrote about that for Frieze and I said, look, I think this is broadly good, it’s an interesting development. I actually liked the work on an artistic level, as well as a sort of social level. But an anxiety I had was that these artists were basically stepping in and doing work that I felt the state, should be doing, and used to do. So I wondered how you felt about that, given that that's also true to an extent of some of the stuff that you were doing at The Turnpike?
HS
I get that. I mean, I love the idea of artists being at the table, because a lot of artists have the vision and can inspire new and surprising perspectives. And I think artists should have a seat with councils, planners and decision makers. But I think, Juliet, that also this approach began to feel a bit Zeitgeist. So we were actually on the ground doing this stuff and I thought it was a moment when smaller organisations like ours would be recognised for that, because we're the ones who've deployed ourselves actively and have done a lot of the groundwork in testing out new and effective approaches. We hoped that this was the moment when those independent radical organisations would gain some recognition for that work; that they'd get more of a voice, they'd get more of a hearing. The Turner Prize shifted, and we thought well great, there's a moment here. There's a moment as we re-emerge when things are going to be done differently, we wanted to hold on to new ways of working. And for a while, you know, the Turner Prize seemed to signal that, for sure. But like I say, I'm hoping that this is not a Zeitgeist thing, a bit of a trend. My anxiety now is that things may start to slip back to the way they were as organisations start to realign once again with their own agendas and funding priorities. But I’m hopeful.
JJ

Well, this is it, I think there's been so much aspiration to go back to ‘normal’ after the pandemic, that a lot of people forgot that ‘normal’ before the pandemic for a lot of people was terrible, was really not good at all. And, you know, lots of us were striving very, very hard to change it. And I guess with the 2019 election, that agenda for change seems to have been pretty decisively rejected. But there were, you know, 10 million people voting for that manifesto and it's important not to lose sight of that.

I was sorry to hear you're winding down what you're doing with The Turnpike. So, can we talk about why that decision has been taken?

HS

Yes, it did perhaps seem like quite an abrupt decision actually. But it wasn't, it took an awful lot of reflection, collectively, to land on that outcome. We’ve had five years with an eye on the future for the role of culture within the town. We tested things out and we've made sure we didn't lose anything in terms of learning, evaluation and sharing those outcomes — the things we learned from collaborating with a really broad array of people and partnerships. I suppose after five years, we came to a crossroads and some of us wanted to move on and try other things. And the simple thing probably for me to do was to just recruit someone in and say, ‘Goodbye, off you go and good luck’. But actually, I knew what a fight it has been to throw a kind of forcefield around that place so that we were able to operate in a way that felt right for us, ethically, socially, creatively. And the idea of leaving it dangling within the current landscape, I just thought it was going to be left very vulnerable to being picked apart by other agendas and could potentially morph into something that it was never meant to be. I’m not conceited enough to say nobody else could lead that organisation because I know there are some brilliant people who could have come in and taken it on. But I was also aware of the bigger context that the organisation had to operate in. And my hope is that another independent, radical organisation will come in and take over when the time is right.

We lay some really fruitful ground, I think, for that to happen. We were always future focused, we've developed artists, we've developed work with communities, we hope we've developed some models of best practice or good practice, at least. We hope we’ve embedded culture into young people's lives and have amplified the importance of cultural education within schools. And we hope we've developed secure partnerships, and a lot of the people that we've secured partnerships with are now taking up the mantle to carry on quite a bit of this work.

The art gallery itself is owned by the local authority who have now taken it back under their ownership as a temporary measure. And so the understanding with them is that they speak to, and listen to, the collective of people who really invested with us and went on this journey with us for five years. That means people from three to ninety-five year-olds, and they’re all there, these people are a gift – they understand the importance of culture in the every day and, understandably, want to shape its future role. Those people should be given a voice, and if they’re not, then they should demand one. All of those artists should be leading this now and I sincerely hope that that happens. Because, frankly, I do believe that if it doesn't, it's not going to work.

JJ

Yes, and you’ve planted that seed. And I think again, during the New Labour period, as well as kind of saying ‘well, if we build galleries in these provincial towns and small cities, then people will come’, there's also been this attitude of ‘well, if there's nothing for you there, or you're bored, just move to the nearest city’, which of course, came back to bite them. So yes, I'd be interested to see if that pendulum swings the other way. And I hope that the work you've done with The Turnpike leads people in Leigh to say, ‘Well, look, we can have a place where the arts contribute to regenerating the town without gentrifying it.’

HS

I hope so, because if this becomes a period now of affectation. If culture is used as a tool for posturing and photo opportunities that enable short-termist agendas, it's just not going to play out. And again, it shouldn't - I'm optimistic that it won't.